Kashmir: A Shark-Infested Heaven on Earth

After having served multiple tenures in J8K, we, a group of three veterans, decided to revisit the pristine Kashmir valley with our wives to experience the post Art 370-abolition environment. It was an eight-day tour from 21 to 28 March 2024. We stayed in local 3/4- star hotels and had a dedicated Innova Crysta for travel.

Kashmir is witnessing an unprecedented rush of tourists. Every single hotel is fully booked. All tourist spots are teeming with hordes of tourists. At some places, even walking is difficult. Surprisingly, most of the tourists were of higher age groups. Apparently, every Indian is keen to get a fint-hand experience of the changed environment. All were happy to observe that J&K had been rescued from the abyss in which it had been sliding. CRPF personnel are doing an admirable job through regular patrolling to instil confidence in the populace

The natural beauty of the valley is unparalleled. It is truly a heaven on earth. But then...

Whereas the Centre has made immense efforts to promote tourism, the local administration has failed miserably. It appears to have washed its hands off all the responsibilities. During our complete visit, we did not come across a single state official or policeman at the tourist places. Local trade unions rule the roost and swindle the helpless tourists. Extortion by the local thugs is rampant and tourists are left to fend for themselves. It is a well-organised mafia operation.

All reputed tour operators issue an advisory to the Kashmir-bound tourists to caution them, "Be very careful while negotiating. Be very clear and certain what you commit and what they commit. Do not get into arguments with them, they can be rude as well. Also beware of vendors like photographers, guides, ponywalas and cab drivers. Remember to take decisions yourself. Do not believe anyone, not even us or the driver or the hotel manager."

Fearing reprisals by the local goons, the tour operators ask the tourists not to tell anyone about the cautionary advice. They beseech, "For any help, call us separately, not in front of anyone, driver, guide, vendors, etc." Can there be a more damning proof of the dreadful state of affairs in Kashmir, wherein even the tour organisers are scared of the mafia?

The Mughal Gardens

Most of them are under renovation. Sadly, their upkeep and maintenance are not up to the mark. At many places the steps need urgent attention. There are no railings. Toilets are too far away and poorly kept. There is always a local goon demanding money for their use. There are no garbage bins. At one garden, security staff at the entry gate was retaining the entry tickets for recycling, thereby pocketing the ill-gotten money.

Doodhpathari

Although an excellent tarred road exits, taxies are stopped 2 km short of the tourist spot (Shaliganga river site) and the tourists are asked to get down. They are given three options to reach the site walk both-ways in high-altitude area (8957 feet); or hire a pony by paying the demanded charges; or ride an ATV (a four wheeled all-terrain vehicle) for a fee of Rs 1,000-1,500 per person. With a single pillion rider straddled behind the driver, it is no option for the ladies. Moreover, an ATV ride is an adventure and only the young can dare. As all the three options are unviable for most tourists, especially the elderly, they never reach the river site. The State government is guilty of succumbing to the local hoodlums and thereby depriving the tourists of reaching Doodhpathari-shameful indeed.

Tarmacked Road to Doodhpathri but Tourists are Forbidden to Use Vehicles and are Forced to Hire Ponies or ATV: Exploitation at its Worst

Sonmarg

It was a lesson in human ingenuity to mint money at the cost of others helplessness. The area was teeming with thousands of tourists, Heavy snowfall had covered the ground with a thick white blanket and the tourists were enjoying playing in the snow. However, lack of basic facilities made the visit a nightmare for most. There were no toilets at all. A few enterprising hotels had erected a tent in their backyard with a solitary pot, common for men and women. Even the path to the tent was terribly slippery as it had not been cleared of snow. Users had to pay Rs 10 each. As it was freezing cold, the queues were long and the walt unbearable for some.

A Common Extortion Racket: Asking a Hapless Lady Tourist to Pay Rs 2,000 for Using Toilet

I have personally witnessed an owner of a third-rate hotel (photo above) declining to let a lady use the toilet unless she hired a room for one hour for Rs 2,000. The hapless lady had tears in her eyes. She paid. It is an open loot of the tourists in connivance with the officials. It defies logic as to why the local authorities cannot build adequate toilet facilities.

Pahalgam

It is around 90 kms from Srinagar. Srinagar taxies are not allowed to take tourists to Aru Valley, Betaab Valley and Chandanwari. They have to hire a local tax-union cab for Rs 2,700. Thus, the tourists and up paying t for two taxies one, that they had brought from Srinagar (lying Idle in Pahalgam) and the second one from the local union.

Although the whole circuit is scheduled to take about 4-5 hrs, the local union drivers keep hurrying up the tourists to save time for the second trip. Worse, they never take the bourists to Chandanwart, stopping 6 km short and turning back. It is outright cheating. They charge for Chandanwarl but go just one km beyond Betaab Valley. There are no officials or policemen to help. The local drivers unite to act as bullies.

Betaab Valley: A Picturesque Tourist Spot where Boulders Provide Privacy for Tollet Shame on the Government

All through the above trip we did not come across a parking areas. It is chaos all around single toilet or a garbage bin or parking areas. It is chaos all around.

Gulmarg

It is around 60 kms from Srinagar. It is a beautiful place, famous for its gondola and the ski slopes. On reaching the place, one is attacked by hordes of guides, ponywalas and other vendors. Once again, to visit Bhutaphatri and the Maharaja Palace, one has to hire a local union taxi for Rs 3,500 as Snnagar taxies are not allowed to go there.

Gondola tickets sold online. Mysteriously, they get sold out within minutes of the opening of sale. According to the local guides, there is a thriving black market in gondola tickets. A ride in gondolas an experience of a lifetime. One is mesmerised by the sheer expanse of the glaciers. Incidentally, gondola hosted over a millón riders in FY 2023-24.

We saw long queues for gondola, entailing wait for up to three hours. There were no shelters or benches for the tourists. Even the snow had not been cleared. Tourists had to hold hands to prevent slipping and falls. One is amazed at the callousness of the organisers. They are minting millions but make no effort to ensure safety and comfort of the tourists

Finally

As J&K has recently emerged from the decades-long turmoil, it enjoys high curiosity quotient. Understandably, tourists are rushing to Kashmir in lakhs. Once the novelty wears off and the current euphoria abates, people will become aware of the real ground situation. Then, Kashmir will be hard pressed to remain a favourite tourist destination.

Air-fairs are sky-high. Srinagar-Dell air-ticket is more than Delhi-Dubal. Hotels are charging exorbitant rentals. A young couple was frank enough to state that Thailand, Dubal and Malaysia were far better organised tourist destinations.

All tourist places in Kashmir are in mountainous/high-altitude areas where the weather remains unpredictable. Bright sun-shine can suddenly turn into heavy rains or snowfall, and even blizzards. Not one place has any shelter or benches for such eventualities. There are no rescue teams or medical and posts. It appears that the government has abdicated Its responsibility totally and will wake up from its slumber only after a major tragedy.

On the morning of our departure, our houseboat caretaker casually asked for the motiles of two guests. Without their permission, he cleverly sent feedback every aspect as excellent ever seen such deviousness. on their behalf, grading every aspect as 'excellent'. Never seen such deviousness.

Despite all my patriotic feelings, I do not recommend a visit to Kashmir as yet. It is ill- organised and ill-prepared to carve the rush of tourists. It lacks elementary Infrastructure, basic amenities and essential facilities at present. Worse, the tourists are always at the mercy of the local mafia. They have to remain on guard at every step. Let the government get its act together and make sure that the tourists are not used as east prey by the shark's that infest the tourism milieu in the much acclaimed "Heaven on Earth".

Article by

Major General Mrinal Suman

AVSM, VSM, PhD, commanded an Engineer Regiment in the Siachen-Kargil sector. He was also the Task Force Commander at Pokhran and was responsible for designing and sinking shafts for the nuclear tests of May 1998. He is a highly qualified officer – B Tech, MA (Pub Adm), MSc (Def Studies) and Doctorate in Public Administration. He is a prolific writer having published nine books and over 550 articles.